Another
paper I wrote dealt with how AI helps increase equity so that ESL students can
keep up with native speakers of English. Equity in education ensures that all
students, regardless of their background, have access to the resources and
support needed to succeed. In Christian universities, this commitment to equity
aligns with core values of inclusivity, service, and justice. These
institutions often emphasize fostering a welcoming and supportive environment
that reflects Christ’s love for all people, including those from diverse
linguistic and cultural backgrounds. By prioritizing equity, Christian
universities fulfill their mission to serve every student as a unique
individual created in God’s image.
Challenges
Faced by ESL Students
Despite
the commitment to equity, ESL (English as a Second Language) students often
face significant challenges that can hinder their academic success: Language
barriers present significant challenges for ESL students in Christian
universities, affecting their ability to fully engage with academic material
and classroom activities. Limited proficiency in English often makes it
difficult for students to comprehend lectures and dense academic texts, leaving
them at a disadvantage in understanding key concepts. Academic writing poses
another hurdle, as students may struggle with structuring essays, using proper
grammar, and adopting an appropriate academic tone, which can impact their
grades and confidence. Additionally, many ESL students hesitate to participate
in class discussions, fearing judgment from peers or the possibility of being
misunderstood. This reluctance can lead to feelings of isolation and a lack of
full integration into the learning community. Addressing these language
barriers is crucial for fostering an equitable and supportive environment where
ESL students can thrive academically and spiritually.
AT
LAPU, the demographic for the common student is a female Hispanic of 29 years.
An LAPU student is a non-traditional adult student who is raising children,
paying a mortgage and has a full time job all at the same time. Some students
are single parents. Many LAPU students are the first in their family to
graduate from college. The most common ESL language is Spanish. As a teacher of
ENGL 101, Prof. Ho has students who may not know how to write a sentence, a
paragraph or know how to put together an academic essay. Students have the
hardest time writing their essay in third person case. Some students struggle
in writing because their first language is not English, but is Spanish.
Cultural
Adjustment:
ESL
students often face challenges navigating unfamiliar cultural norms in a
Christian academic environment, which can differ significantly from their
previous educational experiences. Many may be unaccustomed to the emphasis on
active participation, self-directed learning, and critical thinking that
characterizes Christian university classrooms. These expectations can feel
overwhelming, especially for students from cultures that prioritize deference
to authority or collective learning. Additionally, balancing their own cultural
and religious traditions with those of the Christian university community can
be complex. Students may feel pressure to conform to new practices while
preserving their own identities and faith expressions. This cultural adjustment
process can lead to feelings of alienation or stress, making it essential for
universities to provide support that respects students’ diverse backgrounds
while fostering inclusion. Creating a welcoming and understanding environment
helps ESL students integrate more easily and thrive academically and
spiritually.
Academic
Demands
ESL
students in Christian universities often face the dual challenge of managing a
rigorous academic workload while simultaneously improving their English skills.
The demands of mastering complex subjects are compounded by the need to learn
new vocabulary, refine grammar, and develop fluency in academic writing and
speaking. Many students find it difficult to meet performance standards that do
not always account for the extra effort required to overcome linguistic
challenges, creating additional stress. Furthermore, access to resources
tailored to their needs as non-native speakers is often limited, leaving them
without adequate support. This lack of specific assistance can hinder their
progress and affect their confidence, making it harder to excel. Addressing
these academic demands with targeted resources and inclusive policies can help
ESL students succeed and feel valued in their educational journey. By
addressing these challenges, Christian universities can empower ESL students to
thrive both academically and spiritually, fostering a truly equitable
educational experience.
Many
students who are ESL and speak Spanish as their first language disclose in
their introductions the difficulties they faced in English writing. They
mention in their introduction how when taking ESL/English in high school, they
remember all the red marks of grammar errors, punctuation errors, sentence
structure errors and essay structure errors. When a Spanish speaking student
writes an essay, the make ESL Spanish mistakes. For instance, in Spanish, the
subject is often missing from a sentence. Examp0le: “Is a good house” or “is a good person. Because in Spanish
these sentences are correct. For Spanish speaking ESL students, I often have to
correct these ESL students by telling them that in English we always start the
sentence with the noun/subject. Many ESL students, not just the Spanish
speaking students disclose that they are nervous taking English and writing in
English because English is not their first language. They are nervous to write
essay, and they are nervous to talk to the teacher because they are too
conscious of their English mistakes when speaking or writing.
How
AI helps with Equity with native
students
AI
supports equity for ESL students by providing personalized support that
addresses their unique learning needs and challenges. Adaptive learning
platforms use AI to assess a student’s proficiency level and customize lessons,
ensuring that they receive instruction tailored to their abilities. Writing
assistants like Grammarly or ChatGPT offer real-time feedback on grammar,
sentence structure, and tone, helping students improve their writing skills at
their own pace. Translation tools and speech-to-text software further enhance
accessibility, enabling students to comprehend course materials and participate
in discussions more effectively. Additionally, AI can simulate conversational
practice, allowing ESL students to build confidence in speaking without fear of
judgment. This personalized approach empowers students to overcome language
barriers and fosters a more inclusive learning environment where they can
thrive academically and socially. By addressing individual needs, AI helps
level the playing field and promotes equity for ESL students in educational
settings.
At
LAPU, each LAPU class is outfitted with its own chatbot, virtual teaching
assistant called Spark. Spark AI is
trained on each class’ syllabus, textbook, lectures of that class. The ENGL 101
Spark is not the same as the ENGL 105 Spark. Each one is unique to each class.
If an ESL student has an elementary knowledge of English, the AI can adapt its
English level to the student personalizing the learning experience to the
reading, writing and English level of each student. Spark can help students revise their essay,
brainstorm ideas, and explain complex grammar topics. If an ESL student needs an explanation of a
complex topic in Spanish, AI can explain that complex topic in Spanish. ESL
students are often afraid to ask the teacher because they may not have enough
English to ask the question, the beauty of AI is that it never judges or laughs
at a students’ lack of knowledge or a student’s lack of English creating a safe
space for ESL students to go to.
Enhanced
Accessibility
AI
enhances accessibility for ESL students by integrating tools that make academic
materials more comprehensible and inclusive. Translation tools like Google
Translate and DeepL allow students to instantly translate texts and lectures
into their native languages, bridging gaps in understanding complex course
content. These tools help ESL students keep pace with their peers by enabling
quick comprehension without delaying their studies. Speech-to-text and
text-to-speech software further support diverse learning needs by catering to
auditory and visual preferences. For instance, speech-to-text tools can
transcribe lectures for students who find written notes more accessible, while
text-to-speech software can assist those who grasp information better when it is
spoken. These technologies reduce barriers to learning and empower students to
access materials in ways that best suit their abilities, fostering an equitable
educational experience. By leveraging such AI-driven tools, Christian
universities can ensure that ESL students have the resources they need to
succeed.
What’s
great about Spark AI is that it is available 24/7. Students can ask Spark in
Spanish and ask any questions about how to do an assignment at 3AM in the
morning when the LAPU professor is sound asleep. If there is a three day
weekend where the school is closed, Spark AI is always open while the LAPU
teacher is on vacation. This constant availability of AI helps students keep up
with their schoolwork making students gain confidence and establish a feeling
of belonging in college as the ESL student speaks in Spanish to AI and the AI
speaks back in Spanish. When students understand what is going on in class,
they begin to believe that they will actually succeed in class and maybe even
be the first person in their family to graduate from college. Right now Spark
is text-based, but in the future, Nectir is working on creating a voice-mode
version of their chatbot which will allow ESL students to practice listening
and speaking English skills.
Collaborative Learning Environments
AI
fosters collaborative learning environments that support ESL students by
facilitating meaningful interactions and encouraging equal participation.
Virtual peer-tutoring and language exchange platforms, powered by AI, enable
real-time practice with native speakers, helping students improve their
language skills through conversation and feedback. These platforms also promote
cultural exchange, allowing ESL students to feel more connected to their peers.
AI-assisted discussion forums provide a supportive space for students hesitant
to speak in class, enabling them to participate in discussions by writing
thoughtful responses at their own pace. These forums often include features
like language correction and prompts, which help ESL students refine their contributions
without fear of judgment. By creating opportunities for collaboration and
reducing communication barriers, AI helps ESL students engage more confidently
with their peers and professors, fostering an inclusive and equitable learning
environment.
AI
indeed does increase equity for ESL students to the native speaking students
because armed with the knowledge they gain from Spark, these students are ready
to rumble with the native speaking students in the discussion forums where just
like the native speakers, the ESL students can discuss complex topics of the
lesson of that week stimulating intellectual conversation just as well as a
native speaker evening the odds for an ESL student success of that class. AI
helps erase the awkward Spanish ESL errors that students may have by having
Spark or Grammarly AI correct their ESL Spanish mistakes in their writing. AI
helps ESL students gain confidence in their student academic success.
Alignment
with Christian Beliefs of justice and compassion
AI
integration in education aligns with Christian values by embodying compassion
and service through equitable access for all students, including those who face
language barriers. By providing personalized learning tools and fostering
inclusivity, AI reflects the principle of serving others with love and
understanding. This approach mirrors the teaching of Matthew 25:40, where
serving "the least of these" is equated with serving Christ.
Supporting ESL students with technology demonstrates a commitment to their
academic and spiritual well-being, ensuring they feel valued and empowered
within the university community. It also exemplifies stewardship, leveraging
innovation to create an environment where all students can flourish. In doing
so, Christian universities uphold their mission to reflect Christ’s love and
compassion through their educational practices. AI becomes not just a tool but
a means of fulfilling a higher calling to support and uplift every student.
LAPU
as a Christian university has embraced AI. AT first when ChatGPT first came out
in November 2022, faculty did not know how to react and how to implement a
coherent AI policy. Gradually after many AI training webinars where the more
adventurous LAPU faculty who had played with ChatGPT reported to the other
faculty the amazing ways AI could help students succeed or help teachers save
time. One teacher was amazed at how fast AI could come up with a coherent
sermon. Once LAPU had an AI policy in place, it was up to faculty to teach
students how to use AI ethically to adhere to the newly implemented AI policy.
For instance, Ai policy says that it is okay to use AI to brainstorm ideas,
idea generation and essay revision, but under no circumstance can AI write the
essay for the student.
Limitations
of AI
Implementing
AI to support ESL students requires addressing ethical considerations and
limitations to ensure its effective and responsible use. One key concern is the
potential for bias in AI tools, which may inadvertently perpetuate linguistic
or cultural biases if not carefully monitored and trained on diverse datasets.
Privacy is another critical issue, as safeguarding student data must align with
Christian ethical frameworks that prioritize respect, confidentiality, and
trust. Additionally, over-reliance on technology could undermine the importance
of human mentorship and spiritual guidance, which are essential components of a
holistic Christian education. Maintaining a balance between leveraging AI tools
and fostering personal connections with educators ensures that technology
complements rather than replaces the human element. By addressing these
challenges thoughtfully, Christian universities can integrate AI in a way that
supports equity while upholding ethical standards and their mission to serve
students faithfully.
Case
Students and Real World Examples of Reactions of LAPU Students to AI
At
LAPU, students have reacted positively to AI. Over 85% of LAPU ESL students
report that they have tried out Spark. And a whopping 99% report that Spark has
helped them with idea generation, essay revision, and with understanding complex
topics in class. One student talked with Spark for hours. Spark is programmed
not to do the assignments for the student. Spark is programmed to ask probing
questions about the topic to encourage students to think more profoundly about
the topic. As a result of these probing review questions, Spark AI stimulates a
student’s critical thinking skills by having a back and forth chat interaction
with the student getting the student little by little to write the essay for
himself.
Student:
“Can you help me with my thesis statement?”
Spark:
“What do you know about a thesis statement?”
Student:
Prof. H says it’s the main idea of the essay.
Spark:
What’s the main idea of your essay?”
Student:
I want to write about the benefits of gun control.
Spark:
Why do you think gun control is beneficial?
Student:
In my country, only the police is allowed to have guns. In my country, school
shootings are a rarity. I think if American had more control over who owns guns
like in my country, then there would be fewer school shootings and less
violence.
Spark
coaxes the student little by little to write his own essay by constantly
challenging the student to think about what to write for the essay. Spark is
programmed not to simply regurgitate an answer like ChatGPT. Students love this
interaction with the bot and love talking with it for hours. And they
especially love interacting with the bot in Spanish making them feel more
comfortable with the class material and class assignments. AI makes the
diffuclt assignments more accessible to international students which increases
equity for ESL students through using AI.
AI
plays a pivotal role in addressing the challenges faced by ESL students in
Christian universities, particularly by enhancing language acquisition,
accessibility, and inclusivity. Through personalized support, AI tools like
translation services and speech-to-text software help students overcome
language barriers, ensuring they can engage with academic materials and
participate in class. Additionally, AI fosters collaborative learning
environments and aligns with Christian values by promoting compassion and
service. However, ethical considerations such as bias, privacy, and the balance
between technology and mentorship must be carefully managed. Christian
educators are encouraged to embrace AI as a tool that can create more equitable
learning opportunities while adhering to ethical principles that reflect
Christ’s love and justice. By thoughtfully integrating AI, Christian
universities can offer an inclusive, supportive educational experience that
benefits all students, regardless of their linguistic background.
In
Prof. H’s classes, she encourages students to use both ChatGPT and Spark. She
teaches her students the proper way to use AI ethically. She gives sample chats
she has had with Spark to show students how to interact with Spark by using the
same prompts as she did in her chats with Spark. She also teaches students that
they can use Spark or ChatGPT to talk with the bot in their own language which
usually garners a reaction of surprise and pleasure from the struggling ESL
students. She teaches her students that AI is okay for idea generation, and
essay revision, but it is plagiarism if a student let ChatGPT write the essay
for them. By embracing AI, LAPU increases equity in the classroom which align
with Christian values of compassion and service. When a teacher uses AI to help
ESL students even the playing field they are reflecting Christ’s love for
justice and brotherhood. By integrating AI, ESL students can write, read,
understand and interact with native speaking students on an even playing field.